Can I Date a Non-Believer?

What to Do When Your Heart Wants What God Doesn’t Seem to Approve

You’ve met someone.
They’re kind. Thoughtful. Maybe even better at listening than most Christian guys/girls you’ve dated.
They get you. You laugh together. They’re respectful and emotionally intelligent.
But there’s one thing: They’re not following Jesus.

And now you’re stuck with this question that won’t leave you alone:
Can I date a non-believer?

Honestly? That question isn’t just about dating. It’s about your yes to Jesus.

Let’s dive in.

Start Here: This Is About Your “Yes” to Jesus

This whole conversation starts with one truth:

When Jesus says something isn’t beneficial, it’s not to punish you.
It’s because He’s a kind Father who knows what will lead to joy, freedom, growth, and lasting connection in your future.

Saying yes to Jesus will cost you something. Sometimes that “something” is a really great person who doesn’t love Him like you do. That’s not petty. That’s not legalism. That’s wisdom.

He doesn’t call you away from that relationship because He’s mean. He calls you away because He sees what you don’t yet:

• The conversations you’ll avoid.

• The loneliness that will creep in.

• The division you didn’t see coming.

• The legacy that starts bending in two directions.

But before we get there, let’s look at what Scripture actually says.

What Does the Bible Say About Dating a Non-Believer?

The Bible never mentions dating apps. But it does talk clearly about how we are to align our hearts, lives, and spiritual futures with others.

2 Corinthians 6:14 (NIV)

“Do not be unequally yoked with unbelievers. For what do righteousness and wickedness have in common? Or what fellowship can light have with darkness?”

Paul is using agricultural language here. A yoke was a harness used to tie two oxen together for plowing a field. If one ox is stronger—or heading in a different direction—they’ll end up walking in circles or pulling each other off course.

That’s the picture: if you're yoked to someone who’s not moving toward Jesus, your relationship will either stagnate, split, or pull one person out of alignment.

And most often? It's the believer who slowly quiets their faith to “keep the peace.”

But What If They’re Open or Respectful?

Maybe they say they respect your faith. They’re “spiritual.” Or maybe they’re just not against God—they’re just not into church.

That might feel like enough for now… but what about:

• Who will lead your family spiritually?

• How will you raise kids?

• Will they support you tithing?

• Will you pray together during a crisis?

• Will they celebrate your convictions—or mock them?

You’re not just looking for someone who tolerates your faith. You’re looking for someone who is equally surrendered to Jesus. That’s not religious rigidity—that’s spiritual partnership.

You can’t build a thriving future with someone who doesn’t love the Lord you’ve built your life around.

This Isn’t About Being “Better Than” Them

Please hear this:
Saying you won’t date a non-believer is not about superiority. It’s about compatibility.

Would you date someone who hated kids when you dream of having a big family?
Would you build a life with someone who mocked your career dreams?

So why would you share your soul with someone who doesn’t love the Person you love most?

It’s not judgment. It’s wisdom. It’s stewardship.

You’re guarding the most sacred part of you: your heart and your faith.

Dating Isn’t a Mission Field

You may be tempted to think, “What if I date them and they come to know Jesus?”
Listen—we’ve all heard the stories. And yes, God can use anything. But that doesn’t mean it’s His design.

God may use your compromise, but He doesn’t call you to it.

Nowhere in Scripture are we called to romantically pursue someone with the goal of conversion.

That’s not love. That’s manipulation masked as good intentions.

God doesn’t want you to date someone you need to spiritually drag toward Him. He wants you to walk side by side with someone running after Jesus with their whole heart.

But It Feels So Good Now…

Yeah. Of course it does.

Desire doesn’t mean something is right.
Connection doesn’t mean something is wise.
Comfort doesn’t mean something will last.

This is the hardest part: when your feelings are pulling you one way, but your spirit knows better.

Here’s the truth:

God will sometimes ask you to give up something good to receive something holy.
Not because He’s harsh—but because He knows what’s coming.

If this is the relationship that’s testing your obedience, ask yourself:

• Do I trust Jesus more than I trust my own judgment?

• Am I willing to let go of immediate comfort for long-term joy?

• Am I trying to make God bless something He’s warned me about?

You Can Ask God for His Heart in This

Don’t make this decision based only on logic or pressure.
Get with God.

Take time to:

• Sit in His presence.

• Ask Him: “How do You see this?”

• Ask for His wisdom, not just His permission.

• Ask for peace, not just a green light.

You may not want the answer you hear. But God will never lie to you, and He will always lead you with love.

You might even feel like God is silent. But often, His silence is the echo of something He already told you. You just hoped He’d change His mind.

So… Can I Date a Non-Believer?

You can.
God won’t force your hand.

But if you want a relationship that:

• Points you toward your purpose

• Builds legacy and spiritual unity

• Makes room for deep intimacy without compromise

Then the answer is no.

Because your yes to Jesus will sometimes cost you a relationship—but it will never cost you the joy, fulfillment, and future you were created for.

What If I’m Already Dating a Non-Believer?

This part’s hard. But it’s real.

If you’re already in a relationship, and they’re not following Jesus:

• Don’t ghost them.

• Don’t shame them.

• Don’t play God or demand instant conversion.

But do get honest.
Have a courageous conversation.

You might say:

“I care about you deeply. But I’ve realized that following Jesus fully means I can’t be in a relationship where we’re not spiritually aligned. I’m not ending this out of judgment—I’m choosing obedience.”

Will it hurt? Yes.
Will it be worth it? Absolutely.

God honors obedience. And He will meet you with grace, comfort, and clarity in the aftermath.

Final Thought: You’re Not Alone in This

This isn’t just about dating.
This is about trusting Jesus with your deepest desires—even when it costs you something.

Obedience isn’t easy, but it’s always safe.

God is not withholding love from you. He is protecting your heart, your future marriage, and your purpose.

You deserve a partner who will:

• Worship next to you

• Raise your kids in truth

• Speak life over you

• Pray for you when you’re struggling

• Build a home rooted in the Spirit, not just romance

And God is more than able to lead you to that person.

Want Help Navigating Dating with Purpose?

If you’re wrestling with who to date, how to build boundaries, or how to honor God in your relationships, I wrote a book just for you.

How Far Is Too Far? is your practical guide to dating well, building intimacy the right way, and making decisions that lead to joy, not regret.

👉 Get your copy today at PhysicalBoundaries.com